How to value these numbers in aquarium?
This is a good question. At first we thought that we could transport these values to the aquarium tout-court. Than we filled the aquarium, insert the probe and redone the measurements. We fazed but, as we have already said in elsewhere, we’re going to talk about this in another article. Basically, while at 20 cm the result is practically the same, as we progressed, thanks to the glass and the water itself reflecting the light, we found even the double of the values measured in air. Obviously this isn’t a detail that can be standardized, so we think that our method of calculation is the most correct, and the best for the comparison of coverages of different ceiling lights.
The comparison with other ceiling lights on the market
Recently we started to use the new Apogee’s Quantum Meter MQ-510. For this we can’t completely compare the data of other ceiling lights because before we used the probe Seneye.
Energy | Cost | Consumption | Energy/€ | Energy/w | |
AI Hydra 32 HD at 17 cm | 560.000 | 430 | 90,50 | 1.303 | 6.190 |
AI Hydra 32 HD at 37 cm | 563.000 | 430 | 90,50 | 1.310 | 6.224 |
AI Hydra 32 HD at 57 cm | 463.000 | 430 | 90,50 | 1.076 | 5.112 |
Aqamai LRM at 17 cm | 643.000 | 465 | 90,88 | 1.382 | 7.071 |
Aqamai LRM at 37 cm | 722.000 | 465 | 90,88 | 1.552 | 7.941 |
Aqamai LRM at 57 cm | 616.000 | 465 | 90,88 | 1.326 | 6.783 |
Aqamai LRS at 17 cm | 276.000 | 289 | 47,59 | 955 | 5.797 |
Aqamai LRS at 37 cm | 312.000 | 289 | 47,59 | 1.078 | 6.547 |
Aqamai LRS at 57 cm | 254.000 | 289 | 47,59 | 880 | 5.343 |
ATI Straton at 17 cm | 2.018.232 | 890 | 211 | 2.268 | 9.565 |
ATI Straton at 37 cm | 1.409.595 | 890 | 211 | 1.584 | 6.681 |
ATI Straton at 57 cm | 957.209 | 890 | 211 | 1.076 | 4.537 |
Cetus 2 at 17 cm | 410.000 | 215 | 60,68 | 1.906 | 6.756 |
Cetus 2 at 37 cm | 291.000 | 215 | 60,68 | 1.353 | 4.793 |
Cetus 2 at 57 cm | 174.000 | 215 | 60,68 | 807 | 2.861 |
Orphek OR2 Blue Plus 120 cm at 17 cm | 323.000 | 180 | 54,69 | 1.794 | 5.906 |
Orphek OR2 Blue Plus 120 cm at 37 cm | 291.000 | 180 | 54,69 | 1.616 | 5.321 |
Orphek OR2 Blue Plus 120 cm at 57 cm | 259.000 | 180 | 54,69 | 1.438 | 4.736 |
Orphek OR2 Reef Day Plus 120 cm at 17 cm | 255.000 | 180 | 54,69 | 1.418 | 4.667 |
Orphek OR2 Reef Day Plus 120 cm at 37 cm | 233.000 | 180 | 54.69 | 1.292 | 4.252 |
Orphek OR2 Reef Day Plus 120 cm at 57 cm | 225.000 | 180 | 54.69 | 1.251 | 4.117 |
Philips CoralCare at 17 cm | 1.859.000 | 749 | 190,50 | 2.481 | 9.756 |
Philips CoralCare at 37 cm | 1.341.000 | 749 | 190,50 | 1.790 | 7.037 |
Philips CoralCare at 57 cm | 933.000 | 749 | 190,50 | 1.246 | 4.899 |
The energy per watt is less than the similar Philips Coralcare, but the maximum value is higher. We can say they have similar energy even considering 20 watt less for the consumption of the Philips. This probably depends on the specific LED. The economic efficiency is slightly less then the Philips. In any case, valus of respect. And for now it has the record of energy produced.
Maintenance costs
The ceiling lights ATI Straton cost 890 euro.
The absorbed power is 211 watt, then the relationship cost/watt is 4,22 euro for each watt. You can consult the following chart for the comparison with other ceiling lights. Notice that they’re order for decreasing efficiency, so the best ones are on top.
Ceiling light | Price | Consumption | Relationship euro per watt | References |
Orphek OR2 Blue Plus | 180 USD | 54.7 w | 3,3 euro per watt | DaniReef LAB |
Orphek OR2 Reef Day Plus | 180 USD | 54,7 w | 3,3 euro per watt | DaniReef LAB |
Cetus 2 | 215 € | 60,7 w | 3,5 euro per watt | DaniReef LAB |
Philips CoralCare 2019 | 749 € | 190 w | 3,9 euro per watt | DaniReef LAB |
Maxspect Ethereal | 500 € | 126 w | 4,0 euro per watt | Italian test |
ATI Straton | 890 € | 211 w | 4,22 euro per watt | DaniReef LAB |
Radion XR30w G2 PRO | 790 € | 170 w | 4,7 euro per watt | Italian review |
AI Hydra 32 HD | 430 € | 90,5 w | 4,75 euro per watt | DaniReef LAB |
Radion XR30w G4 PRO | 915 € | 190 w | 4,84 euro per watt | Italian article |
OceanLed Sunrise 600 | 870 € | 180 w | 4,8 euro per watt | Italian test |
Orphek Atlantik V4 | 1099 € | 226 w | 4,9 euro per watt | Test |
Radion XR30w G2 | 690 € | 140 w | 4,9 euro per watt | Italian review |
Radion XR30w G4 | 760 € | 150 w | 5,1 euro per watt | Italian article |
Aqamai LRM | 465 € | 87,5 w | 5,1 euro per watt | DaniReef LAB |
Zetlight UFO ZE-8000 | 500 € | 91,5 w | 5,5 euro per watt | Test |
Aqamai LRS | 289 € | 47,6 w | 6,1 euro per watt | DaniReef LAB |
CEAB Slide & Led | 2.700 € | 275 w | 9,8 euro per watt | Review |
Sicce GNC 466 | 1.592 € | 120 w | 13,3 euro per watt | Review |
The ceiling light is extremely well build, firm and solid. Very beautiful. The energy efficiency is high but the cost per watt is rather low. The values are perfect for nanoreef and for aquariums until 70 cm per side, both for breed SPS and every other animal. Increasing the sizes of the aquarium the covering decreases, so I suggest 2 of these ceiling lights in 120 cm and 3 in 180. The energy is linear on the water column.
Questions and comments, as always, are welcomed.
The ATI imported and distributed by AGP.